Good Customer Service Does Not Include Obfuscation
This post is a slight departure from my normal entries and I wasn't even sure whether to put it in this blog. However, on reflection, it is quality related, or should I say, lack of quality! And it's about failing quality of both product and service.
I've recently had a couple of issues with my ISP (BT Total Broadband), one relating to the TV service (BT Vision), the second relating to their e-mail service (BT Yahoo Mail). In both cases I have posted comments on Twitter which have been picked up by the @BTCare customer service Tweeter, and have resulted in a series of farcical interactions and no resolution of the issues. But first let's quickly look at the problems.
The BT Vision Problem
BT Vision is BT's service offering set up to 'compete' in the Sky/Virgin TV space. The reality is that it only really offers Freeview TV channels, a limited On Demand service and a PVR Box. You pays your money and you makes your choice. It's adequate for my needs but that isn't the issue here. The issue is with the design of the software which runs on the BT Vision PVR box. As would be expected it is possible to record TV shows and series. And it's this latter task which drives me to despair. You cannot simply record a series on specific day/time/channel - the default setting is to record the "first run and any repeats". And given the number of repeats on UK TV this becomes a real issue. Simple example - I set BT Vision to record "Hairy Bikers' Bakeation" on BBC 2 on Tuesday at 20:00. By default this will also record the same show on BBC2 on Thursday at 19:00. Why anyone would want to do this is quite beyond me. To prevent the duplicate recording I have to edit the series recording settings and change the setting to "First Run Only". This is made quite time consuming because of the bizarre UI, but quite simply it shouldn't be necessary!
@BTCare picked up on my whinge on Twitter and I was asked to submit a problem form via the BT website which I duly did. I received no less than four telephone messages on my answer machine explaining how to change the settings (but not the defaults). This was after I had explained in no uncertain terms that the only solution to my particular problem was to redesign and rewrite the software!
The BT Yahoo Mail ProblemI use Apple Mail on my Mac to access my email from the BT Yahoo Mail service. Most of the time this works perfectly but on occasions the mail servers throw a wobbler and reject the password. This situation can last for minutes to hours and is well documented on the BT Forums (One query has generated 56 pages of related comments). Usually the problem goes away by itself, but it is clearly a bug and appears to happen on other third party mail clients (on Windows also) so is not an Apple Mail specific problem.
The latest "fix" that @BTCare suggested is that I shouldn't have more than one mail client trying to access mail at any one time. In other words, when I'm at home I have to turn off 'push' mail on my iPhone/iPad, and when I go out I have to close Mail on my Mac. Apparently this is also a requirement of Yahoo Mail policy (although no-one seems to be able to find the policy written anywhere).
Once again, I have been invited to submit my issue to BT via their website. On this occasion I've declined as it just leads to a series of useless telephone messages.
The Morals of the StoryThere are two conclusions I have come to from these (so far unresolved) issues. The first is that Twitter is far from an ideal medium to manage customer service and customer relations. It may provide a "front" to demonstrate that the business cares about its customers and can be seen to be actively managing issues, but it is nothing more than that.
The second is that deliberate obfuscation of issues can hardly be considered as good practice for dealing with real problems. With both my issues, I have been palmed off with useless responses which show no understanding of the real problem, and exhibit little willingness to even try to really deal with the problems to any degree of customer satisfaction.
Even a basic acknowledgement of my issues and a genuine response (such as "we understand your frustration and have raised a change request for consideration") would help.
BT Customer relations managers and help desk managers could do with reading John Seddon's book "Freedom From Command and Control" and learn the difference between value and failure demand!
Of course, I could show my dissatisfaction by changing my ISP. All I would achieve by doing this would be to swap one set of issues with a different set and cause me a huge amount of inconvenience, time and money - not least of which would be caused by losing my primary email address which I have had for the past ten or more years!
In other words - bite off my nose to spite my face! No thanks, but at the same time - BT: thanks for nothing!